Investors who hold their nerve stand to emerge as winners
Property markets may have further to fall, but investors who track key economic and real estate indicators can spot the signs of recovery and identify opportunities before confidence fully returns.
There’s little doubt anymore that both the economy and wider property markets are heading south.
Residential property values are falling, yields on commercial property are rising along with the cost of money (interest rates), new construction is falling (the opposite of what the Federal Government intended), unemployment is rising (with an outlook further clouded by the impact of AI on the jobs market), real per capita GDP is falling, and consumer spending is drying up as people watch their pennies much more closely.
Sounds like dystopia, right? Much as none of this is welcome, the good news is that we’ve been here before. I’ve lived through a few and am here to tell the tale. It’s not the end of the world, though at the time it feels like it.
In the recession of 1990-91 (“the recession we had to have” according to then Treasurer Paul Keating) credit flows just stopped. I was working in a commercial agency at the time as a research manager, and we turned up to work one day to find the office doors locked.
No redundancy then, and mortgage rates were around 15 per cent when the music stopped. So we did what any self-respecting, newly unemployed Aussie would do in the circumstances: we went to the pub for a very long session. Somehow, we muddled through in the months ahead and the economy soon enough stabilised, even with unemployment rates in the double digits.
The GFC of 2008-2009 was another sorry time. Global wealth was decimated. Money was tight. Then there was Covid of course, and literally everything stopped – only to be propped up by insane levels of government stimulus to prevent the wheels falling off the bus.
‘Buy in gloom, sell in boom’
So, while the economy is likely to worsen further before it improves (may as well use the term recession because, per capita, that’s what’s happening right now), the trick is to look for the signs that we have reached a bottom. If you can access capital, buying at the bottom is a time proven investment strategy. “Buy in gloom, sell in boom” is as true today as it ever was.
What are the signs the market has hit bottom, and begun to turn?
For me, in real estate it’s not prices, because these usually lag the other indicators. You could start by keeping a close watch on ‘days on market’, which will blow out when markets soften, and begin to tighten quickly as confidence returns.
Unsold stock listings will also begin to reduce as buyers return. Auction clearance rates and sales volumes are an obvious indicator also. Watch the tone of general media stories too – as the bad news stories begin to change to ‘is this the time to buy?’ stories, you could rightly assume a sense of confidence is returning to the markets.
But real estate is typically a function of the wider economy. What are the economic signals you could be tracking to pick the bottom?
The early signs of a recovery
Just as prices in real estate are a lagging indicator, unemployment can also lag a turnaround. In fact, unemployment can continue rising while a recovery is underway: it takes time for employers to rebuild cash flows and business demand before taking on new staff. Job advertisements are a better leading indicator than unemployment, because they reflect the ‘what happens next’ in the employment market.
Have a look also at things like retail spending data from the ABS. As consumer confidence returns, that usually translates into household spending, especially if purchases during a downturn have been deferred. Household confidence surveys (there are many) are also worth keeping tabs on.
Business condition surveys and business confidence surveys are also good indicators of general optimism (or the lack of it). The US economy seems to have many more measures of inventory, ordering intentions and so on compared with Australia, but they’re a valuable insight if you can track them.
And then of course there are the reports from the RBA, issued on a regular basis when decisions on interest rates are announced.
Falling interest rates will be welcome, but in themselves may not be the indicator that the bottom has been reached. In the past, falling interest rates have been introduced to try stimulate what’s left of the economy after a recession. It can take time before lower rates translate into improving health for the economy.
World events cannot be ignored either – they impact the cost of capital, and things like energy prices affect entire economies.
In the old 1983 movie Trading Places actor Eddie Murphy explained to his wealthy benefactors why pork belly futures prices were falling – traders were selling off in a pre-Christmas panic. He told then to hold their nerve and buy at the bottom – which they did, and which made them a lot of money as the market turned.
Watching for signs the market has bottomed, and why, is what many seasoned investors would be doing right now. Hold your nerve … it will get worse and if you can pick the turn, you’ll probably do well.













