Interest rates, rental reforms put NSW property market under pressure

A fifth interest rate rise in a year is adding pressure to property owners and buyers, while NSW housing and rental reforms risk driving investors away and worsening the state's rental crisis.

NSW Government crest
REINSW has implored the NSW State Government to apply a light regulatory touch when addressing the housing crisis. (Image source: State of New South Wales through the Parliament of New South Wales)

This summer, the subdued real estate market will grapple with the outcomes of a fifth interest rate rise in a year.

Much has been written about interest rates being a blunt instrument interest rates being a blunt instrument when it comes to curbing persistent inflation. Amid the strong influence of various global factors, not least the high cost of oil, hiking interest rates is proving ineffective.

The Reserve Bank’s mandate is pretty clear-cut. If inflation is too high, increase rates. The fact that such a move disproportionately impacts mortgage holders is not the RBA’s concern.

But the ramifications are everyone’s concern. The risk of recession grows, unemployment rises, and even NSW Premier Chris Minns concedes that there will be some “shops that close that do not reopen”.

Thankfully, the ill-conceived price disclosure reforms that were to come into effect on November 17 were abandoned by the NSW Premier at the last minute.

REINSW strongly advocated against the reforms on the basis of the adverse impacts they would have on vendors and buyers.

A vendor should not be prohibited from seeking the market price for their property. In a distressed market, that may be less than the market would have paid at the beginning of the marketing campaign.

Practical examples of the shortcomings of the reforms are plentiful. A vendor may need an urgent sale because of illness, the need to move quickly, a sudden change in financial circumstances (remember, rates are rising), or countless other reasons.

Yet, because a vendor has refused an offer, the agent would have been prevented from advertising a price lower than the rejected offer, despite the market moving downward.

REINSW has welcomed the Premier’s decision to walk away from these bad reforms. But other recent reforms continue to have a negative impact on consumers.

The real estate industry has been subject to about 2,500 individual legislative changes in the last 12 months alone. Many of these are experienced by agents and their businesses internally, with no consequences for consumers.

But some of these changes are being experienced by the market.

In NSW, we have an entrenched rental crisis. The fault lies largely with successive state governments.

There has been failure to foster, over many years, an environment in which housing supply can be delivered in line with increased housing demand.

The failure too, to recognise that investors are consumers as well and are making their properties available for people to rent. If you push them away, they will invest their money elsewhere.

There is the disingenuity in demonising landlords, as though it will help tenants, when these investors do leave the market, the disingenuity of Government claiming it is fighting for tenants’ rights when in effect, it is robbing tenants of choice.

Then there is a failure to grasp that applying more tax to an investment class negatively impacts the attractiveness of investing in it.

In a free market, Government should have a light regulatory touch. To do otherwise causes more problems than it solves.

Article Q&A

How are rising interest rates affecting the Australian property market?

Further interest rate rises are putting pressure on mortgage holders, buyers and property owners, potentially weakening housing demand and increasing the risk of distressed sales as household finances tighten.

Why were the proposed NSW property price disclosure reforms abandoned?

The NSW Government abandoned the planned reforms after strong industry opposition, including from REINSW, which argued they could prevent agents from advertising a property at a lower price even when market conditions had shifted and a vendor needed to sell.

How could NSW rental reforms make the housing crisis worse?

The article argues that policies placing additional costs and restrictions on property investors risk making residential property less attractive as an investment. If investors sell or redirect their money elsewhere, fewer rental properties may be available, further limiting tenants’ choices.

Continue Reading Policy ArticlesView all policy articles