Housing policies backfire as buyers retreat and rental crisis worsens

Six months after the Federal Budget promised to ease housing pressures, falling home loan commitments, collapsing investor lending and weaker new-home sales suggest the changes are discouraging investment without delivering the new supply Australia needs.

Man outside near house, renting new home.
Australians are increasingly turning their back on property investment. (Image source: Volodymyr TVERDOKHLIB/Shutterstock.com)

The Federal Government promised its May Budget would improve Australia’s housing crisis, help first home buyers, encourage investors to build new dwellings and have minimal impact on rents.

It hasn’t. Six months later, the evidence is overwhelming that the policies have failed spectacularly. And the damage is spreading well beyond the housing market.

The combination of controversial changes to property taxation and five interest rate rises in 2026 has smashed buyer confidence, devastated new home sales, undermined construction activity, damaged businesses that rely on a healthy real estate market and slashed state government revenue.

Meanwhile, renters – supposedly among the beneficiaries of the Budget – are facing worsening shortages and rapidly rising rents.

The numbers are extraordinary.

Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show that new housing loan commitments fell 15 per cent in the September quarter alone, including a record 30 per cent collapse in investor loans.

First home buyer lending fell 8.6 per cent in the quarter, following an earlier decline in the June Quarter. Every month, there are fewer Australians buying their first homes.

This is the very group that  were supposed to benefit from the Federal Government changes.

The Reserve Bank’s five interest rate increases, caused in large part by runaway Federal Government spending, have compounded the damage by reducing borrowing capacity and increasing mortgage repayments.

The big banks are reporting declines in home loan applications but perhaps the most alarming figures concern the construction of new homes.

One of the nation’s biggest home builders, Stockland, has recorded a staggering 71 per cent decline in buyer inquiries for its residential developments. Mirvac’s September-quarter sales are down 31 per cent, compared to the same time last year.

This is disastrous for a nation already suffering a massive housing shortage.

When developers cannot achieve sufficient pre-sales, they struggle to secure construction finance and projects are postponed or abandoned.

Building approvals eventually decline, construction commencements fall and the shortage of completed dwellings becomes even worse.

And the economic consequences don’t stop at the building site.

Not enough homes being built

Every property transaction generates business for mortgage brokers, conveyancers, building inspectors, removalists, cleaners, tradespeople and many others.

New homeowners buy furniture, appliances, carpets, curtains, paint and garden equipment. When property sales collapse, all those businesses suffer. More and more of these businesses are reporting adverse impacts - and employees are losing their jobs.

There is another major casualty: state government revenue. Falling property transactions and declining values mean less stamp duty flowing into government coffers.

That’s money state governments won’t have for hospitals, schools, transport and essential services – unless they borrow more or increase other taxes.

But the cruellest consequences are emerging in rental markets.

The Government claimed its tax changes would encourage investment in newly constructed dwellings while adding only around $2 per week to rents.

But realestate.com.au data shows that rents increased $10 per week nationally in the September quarter alone.

The fundamental problem remains unchanged: Australia isn’t building enough homes.

The Budget has discouraged investors without successfully redirecting them into new construction. Higher interest rates have made the situation worse.

First home buyers are retreating, businesses are suffering, government revenues are shrinking and tenants are paying the price.

Article Q&A

Have the Federal Government’s housing policies improved affordability?

The evidence presented six months after the May Budget suggests they have not. New housing loan commitments fell 15 per cent in the September quarter, investor lending plunged 30 per cent and first-home buyer lending dropped 8.6 per cent, while rents continued to rise.

How have the Budget changes affected property investors?

Investor lending fell by a record 30 per cent in the September quarter. The article argues that changes to property taxation, combined with higher interest rates, have weakened investor confidence without successfully redirecting investment into newly constructed homes.

What impact are weaker property sales having on new housing supply?

Falling buyer demand is making it harder for developers to secure the pre-sales needed to obtain construction finance. Projects can then be postponed or abandoned, reducing future building approvals and construction commencements and worsening the housing shortage.

Why are renters still facing higher rents despite the Government’s promises?

The Government suggested its tax changes would add only around $2 a week to rents, but national rents increased by $10 a week in the September quarter alone. Australia is still not building enough homes, while weaker investor activity and higher borrowing costs are adding to the supply challenge.

Continue Reading Policy ArticlesView all policy articles